Thought Exercise: The Drive Socket

0
Aaron from Michigan lamented the weight and clumsiness of using a heavy steel socket and adapters to lightly torque 1⅞-inch axle nuts. The solution: Make a custom socket in the home shop.

Ever look at a part and wonder, “How did they make that?” I do that all the time. When the solution isn’t particularly obvious, it becomes a thought exercise, as in, “How would I make that?”

This month’s project started out as one of those thought exercises. The project was suggested by Aaron from Michigan, who was looking for a light-duty 1⅞-inch socket for tightening large axle nuts to a very low, but precisely calibrated, torque specification:

“My company requires all wheel hub nuts to be torqued with a socket [not a crowfoot wrench]. This is an issue with military birds as well. The size of the axle nut requires you to use a ¾-inch drive socket with adapters to get down to the inch-pound torque wrench, which has a ⅜-inch drive. The socket and adapters are heavy and stupid. Having a 1⅞-inch socket with a ⅜-inch drive and as small as possible would be amazing.”

The top drawing reflects the first series of operations necessary to create the final hex pocket. The bottom drawing is the finished part. Download this file.

Sockets are usually steel, but when the application requires non-magnetic or non-conductive tools, you can find sockets made of brass, aluminum-bronze and even plastic. But there’s really nothing out there—at least that I could find—that fit what Aaron was looking for: a light-duty 1⅞-inch socket with a ⅜-inch drive socket. In other words, exactly the kind of project for the home shop machinist!

I did a quick sketch to get an idea of the machining stock needed. Since I planned on using aluminum from the get-go, I supposed it would be a good idea to make the corners of the socket a very robust ¼ inch thick. Not so much to prevent a blowout during use, but to give the tool some resilience when getting banged around in a toolbox. This drove the outside diameter to 2½ inches. The overall length was left “to be determined” because I knew the “how to make it” part of the process would have to be figured first.

The rem that became the machining stock needed to have the rough ends squared up on the mill to be held securely in the four-jaw chuck.
A live center was used to dial in the center of the blank in the four-jaw chuck (left). For more information on four-jaw chucks, see “The Lathey Guy’s Guide to Work Holding” (KITPLANES, September 2014). The corners were knocked off with repeated 0.050-inch passes (right).

As I rummaged around my collection of rems and cutoffs, I was hoping to find some 2½-inch round solid bar stock. For this project, I didn’t need much. I was thinking two inches would do it. No such luck. A couple of calls to neighbors to scrounge their bins also proved fruitless. A number of online suppliers could sell me what I needed…as long as I could wait a week! Who wants to wait a week?

Notice the tool orientation is “upside down” and the lathe rotation reversed for knocking off the corners (left). To finish the “round,” the four-jaw chuck was swapped out for the three-jaw self-centering chuck to turn the blank to the final size (right).
Making the socket cavity and holding stem required using the milling machine to rough out a ¾-inch-deep doughnut-shaped cavity (left). Note how the three-jaw chuck (with the blank clamped in place) was taken off the lathe and fixed to the rotary table with hold-downs (right).
The three-jaw chuck and blank were reinstalled on the lathe to turn the precise inside diameter of the socket cavity (left) and outside diameter of the stem (right).
The stem for the ¾-inch hex was roughed down using 0.050-inch passes (left) until reaching the specified one-inch diameter (right).

During my initial search I spied a potential “Plan B” option among the rems: a decidedly non-round slug of aluminum roughly 2½x3x2. Not a problem. After squaring up the ends on the mill, I used the four-jaw independent chuck to turn it into a round bar.

Mounting the blank to the 5C indexer (left) for milling the hex flats (right).
After the hex was milled, the stem was removed (left) and the bottom of the socket cavity “cleaned up” with a light pass (right).
With a locating stop secured to the mill vise, the hex flats were used to index the placement of the six drilled holes, which make up the corner reliefs in the socket (left). A four-flute ¼-inch end mill was used to mill the flats between corners. The holes provided a visual reference when to stop, retract the cutter and index the part for the next flat. The locating stop ensured repeatability of positioning (right).
The final operation was to remove the burrs and round over the edges of the socket flats with a hand file.

With suitable material in hand, how to make the socket cavity more or less popped into my head. By milling a ¾-inch hex protrusion on the drive end, I could use that for indexing the hex socket. Super simple, super easy. One minor problem: My blank wasn’t long enough to make a suitable length stem to use the 5C indexer to mill the designed hex. A couple of quick measurements confirmed that I didn’t need to make a protruding stem! The inside circle of the socket hex (1⅞, same as the distance across the flats) was big enough to fit over the nose of the indexer (refer to the photos). I designed a suitable clamping stem to be made during the preliminary socket cavity excavation (see drawing). The stem would be turned away after milling the hex.

If Aaron doesn’t like the idea of having to use a separate ¾-inch socket, the quick and dirty solution will be to J-B Weld a ¾-inch socket permanently to the hex drive. It won’t add much weight and it’ll never get lost. That’s it for now; time to get back in the shop to clean up the chips from this project—and there were a lot!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.